A registered dietitian on a quest to help my clients (and now you) find the best clean products on the market based on your need ❤️
I used to fall asleep in 2 minutes flat, every night. But as I got older, my sleep got worse. I'd be exhausted all day, but as soon as my head hit the pillow? Mind racing. Restless legs. Wide awake. When I finally fell asleep at 3 am, I’d wake up tossing and turning an hour later.
It was a nightmare, except I’d actually prefer a nightmare because at least I’d be asleep.
I’d tried melatonin gummies that barely worked and made me super drowsy the next day. I wanted something different. Something convenient that I could take every night. So I decided to test and review the most popular sleep gummy brands I found online, and narrow them down to these top 4 options.
Everyone’s sleep struggles look different - some have trouble falling asleep, others wake up with a racing mind at 3 a.m., and many feel a brutal hangover when they wake up.
And some of us struggle with all the above.
But most people don’t want a hardcore sleep aid, or prescription fix. They want something gentle and natural, that eases them into relaxation without feeling like a zombie the next day or becoming dependent on a strong sedative just to chill.
So when I started paying attention to sleep gummies, I gravitated toward options that felt gentle and supportive. Something that fits into an already decent bedtime routine, not something that tries to replace it.
✅ Melatonin-Free Formula
✅ Magnesium Glycinate is a Massive Plus
✅ Calming Ingredients like L-Theanine
✅ No Next-Day Grogginess
✅ Natural Science-Based Formula
✅Works in an Hour or Less
✅ Tastes great
1. Only Chose Top Brands: Focused on the most popular gummies that were recommended by Doctors, had great reviews, and were top sellers on multiple platforms…that way, I left out the worst options.
2. Evaluated How I Felt the Morning After: Did I feel well rested and energized or was I super groggy and needing an IV of caffeine to operate? Because the whole reason you want better nights is to have better days.
3. Reviewed Ingredient Lists: I looked at the forms of magnesium used, whether it had melatonin, and eliminated options with ingredients linked to grogginess or digestive discomfort…because nobody wants that.
4. Paid Attention to Sweeteners: Made sure that the gummies didn’t use a massive amount of sugar or corn syrup. I didn't want to add a couple hundred calories just to sleep. Plus, too much sugar can disrupt sleep because it forces your body to release cortisol.
5. Ranked the taste: Might not be super important to everyone, but If it doesn’t taste good I’m not going to continue using it night after night.
✅ Uses The Best Forms of Magnesium for Restful Sleep
✅ Offers Calming L-Theanine & Apigenin
✅ Adds 8 Essential Daily Vitamins for Added Health Benefits
✅ Has No Melatonin, Which Means No Groggy Mornings
✅ Formulated with Vegan and Gluten Free Ingredients
✅ Undergoes 3rd Party Lab Testing for Guaranteed Safety
✅ Skips Artificial Sweeteners, Colors, or Preservatives
✅ Comes with a 60-Day Money Back Guarantee So There’s No Risk In Trying
❌ Not Made for “Knockout” Seekers.
❌ Sold Out Quickly When it First Came Out, But It's in Stock Now
❌ 4 Gummies in Each Pack Might Seem Like Too Much for Some
These MoonBrew gummies were my favorite. By using the two best forms of magnesium for sleep, this gummy relaxes the nervous system and calms the mind. That’s exactly what I needed to get into bed without the restlessness and racing thoughts I normally had.
But I especially love that they contain L-Theanine that reduces stress and promotes tranquility without the drowsiness of melatonin or OTC sleeping pills.
The real result is the next morning. After getting over 7 hours of deep, restful sleep, I could wake up feeling energized. I never even had to hit the snooze button…not one time.
Each little pack of MoonBrew gummies contains clean ingredients and essential vitamins, without artificial sweeteners, dairy, gluten, or nuts.
And honestly, the best part is that anyone can try MoonBrew Sleep + Vitamin Gummies without risking any money. That’s because they offer a 60-day money back guarantee…if it doesn’t work, you can get a full refund.
While I loved these gummies the best, they still aren’t perfect. They probably won’t work for everyone, especially people who have intense sleep issues like major insomnia.
Additionally, while they taste great, they only come in one flavor, strawberry. It’s not my favorite, so hopefully they add more in the future.
I would also say they are a little expensive, but you can get up to 35% off, which is actually less than $2 for the best sleep you’ll ever have, every night.
✅ Uses organic, plant-based ingredients
✅ Contains GABA & Reishi which are good for sleep
✅ Melatonin-free
✅ Lab tested for heavy metals
❌ Didn’t feel any onset when I took it
❌ More for relaxation & not staying asleep
❌ Had to double up on each serving which would make it cost a lot
The formula & ingredients are good: I really like that these are melatonin-free and contain a lot of organic, plant based ingredients (like Reishi, Chamomile, and Elderberry).
No artificial sweetness overload: The taste was really good - some of the gummies stuck together which was annoying, but it was easy to take.
Didn’t feel the sleep onset that heavily: Good formula, but I think not having magnesium (and melatonin for that matter) make it a lot less powerful vs. others on the list.
Had to double up a few nights: I really wanted to make these work so I ate 4 instead of 2 on certain nights, but that would make it expensive long-term to use nightly.
✅ Melatonin-free
✅ Uses Magnesium Glycinate
✅ L-theanine and Valerian combo is great
✅ High doses of each ingredient
❌ My tummy isn't a fan of the Maltitol + Xylitol combo
❌ Shipping took forever
❌ Causes some next-day drowsiness
Lullabites did exactly as advertised: put me to sleep fast. The addition of valerian root seems to work for quick relaxation.
They also use l-theanine, just like my favorite option on this list, MoonBrew Sleep + Vitamin Gummies. Lullabites taste great, and look like little cute stars. The packaging and designs are all good now that I think about it.
While these worked better than most options I tried, I did have a couple of major issues when I tried these gummies.
First, the sugar substitutes Maltitol and Xylitol in the formula are actually mild laxatives. So each night and most mornings, I felt bloated and had some pretty bad stomach cramps.
Second, while these things definitely work, it’s kind of overwhelming. They are really powerful to take every night, causing extreme drowsiness and some next morning grogginess.
✅ Taste Like Candy
✅ Put me to sleep fast
✅ Good ingredients like L-theanine & Chamomile
❌ Contains 5mg of Melatonin
❌ Put me to sleep fast but then I woke up multiple times at night
❌ Only a small amount of Magnesium
❌ Left me with a slight hangover effect the morning after 1 night I tried them
If you’re looking for candy, this is a great option. Super delicious. Plus, they do help quite a bit with falling asleep faster and there are noticeable calming effects. I think that's the L-Theanine.
They also don’t have corn syrup or gluten, which is an added bonus. Lemme Sleep positions themselves as drug-free, which is obviously a great thing, but so are all the others on my list.
As you already know, I don’t like melatonin, which hurts Lemme Sleep. They leave me waking up super groggy and cause vivid dreams, often nightmares.
They also don’t seem to last as long as other gummies, maybe because of the low amount of magnesium. I kept waking up in the middle of the night tossing and turning again, yet still really drowsy.
✅ The combo of melatonin and l-theanine definitely puts you to sleep
✅ Great brand with lots of good products available at basically every retailer
✅ Affordable pricing compared to every other product I reviewed
❌ The melatonin knocked me out which I wouldn't be able to do nightly
❌ Better for jet lag & special occassions
❌ Didn't taste very good to me
These Olly gummies definitely help you fall asleep, which makes them a good emergency option for nights when I’m extra wired or nervous.
But the best part about these is that I can find them at Target, CVS, and pretty much any major store for an affordable price. So, if I accidentally run out of MoonBrew Sleep + Vitamin Gummies, I know Olly is a good option in a pinch.
My biggest complaint about Olly Max Strength gummies is that they contain a high dose of melatonin, which makes me super drowsy in the morning. Because of that, they are better for occasional use than nightly sleep.
I also wish it had magnesium glycinate or l-theanine for added relaxation without the drowsiness caused by melatonin.
These are my favorite four sleep gummies, which means you can’t really go wrong with any of them. That being said, the only one I keep buying month after month is MoonBrew. The gentle, fast-acting relaxation makes these gummmies the perfect choice for long-term sleep.
And, as I mentioned earlier, it’s not just the full night of sleep that’s important…it’s the next morning when I feel awake and productive even before my first cup of coffee.
You can even try them with an extra discount by tapping the button below and using the code: REVIEWBOARD24. Remember, if they don’t work, you can get every penny back within 60 days.
Want to save on your new favorite thing? Sign up for discount codes, new launches, and editors' picks.
